The visible minority blues....
I was listening to CBC radio the other morning (which is clearly dangerous to my health) and they aired a piece about visible minorities and the law. To the CBC, and their experts, the fact that so-called 'visible minorities' were 'over-represented' in being arrested. This was 'proof' of institutional racism.
That was the whole report. No questions asked.
But I have some:
1. Do we really have to divide the world into 'visible minorities' and 'non-visible minorities' which really means caucasians???
2. Are 'visible minorities' monolithic? Isn't it insulting to lump so many people together in one pool? Couldn't we delve a little deeper? For instance, there are probably minorities, liket Chinese, who probably don't run foul of the law that often.
3. Why do we use a ridiculous statistic to prove a charge of institutional racism? We have institutional racism because a proportionately high ratio of visible minorities are arrested...and a proportionately high ratio of visible minorities are arrested because of institutional racism. It's a tautology.
4. Can't the CBC find anybody with a contrary opinion?
We all deserve better. We deserve to know if any particular group has a problem in breaking the law. They might just deserve to be arrested. But, to combat the problem we need to understand what it is.
3 Comments:
Men are over-represented in crime statistics; does that mean there is an inherent anti-male sexism in the system?
Well, in Toronto, blacks account for about 90% of the gun crimes, and 10% of the population.
You do the math :-)
It's not that the majority of visible minorities are criminals, but that the majority of criminals are visible minorities.
If there is a disproportionate amount of minorities in jail, then perhaps its because they are committing a disproportionate amount of the crime. Its not a very difficult concept to grasp.
And why are the people who are immigrating to this country and committing crimes allowed to stay?
Post a Comment
Subscribe to Post Comments [Atom]
<< Home